NAPALM DEATH - SCUM
The legendary 1987 debut of UK grindcore pioneers remains a benchmark of murkily recorded, politically informed intensity.
1) Tape bought in Our Price records, Perth in (I think) 1988. Listened almost to death, there is something very right about the cassette version of Scum, not least because of the endless list of acknowledgments and thanks, which, in the pre-internet age was extremely useful in spreading the word about underground music. The almost indiscernible, bleached out band photo is fun too.
2) CD bought a few years ago for convenience. It lacks the homemade qualities of the tape and omits the sleevenotes altogether, as well as using a very wrong font for the song titles in the booklet, but it's nice to have photos of both lineups and I'm glad they used the yellow cover & not the green/blue/etc variants. Of course there's another new version out now, which I will end up buying too.
MORRISSEY - VIVA HATE
Morrissey's 1987 debut solo album isn't quite The Smiths, but definitely has its own charm, with guitarist Vini Reilly playing some of the most un-Johnny Marr yet heroically un-macho guitar known to man.
1) Tape bought in the very early 90s, played to death
2) LP, bought some time later, second hand, partly for the sleeve, although it doesn't have the same profile portrait of Moz in the inner as the tape & CD
3) CD, bought for convenience, strangely the colour of the artwork has a more brownish hue than the LP and especially the tape, which are markedly more blue-ish
The Cure - Boys Don't Cry - Japanese Whispers - 17 Seconds - Faith - Kiss Me, Kiss Me, Kiss Me - Pornography - Disintegration
In my last year or two of high school I think I bought pretty much Cure album to date (that is, up to Wish), mostly on tape (my preferred format at the time, easily carried around and I didn't yet have a CD player). Most of these were later replaced by CDs for convenience and by vinyl, because it sounds better and for aesthetic reasons; which is funny in a way because some of my favourites (Faith, 17 Seconds) have extremely drab covers.
Suicidal Tendencies - How Will I Laugh Tomorrow...When I Can't Even Smile Today
Sheer genius; hardcore punks go 80s thrash but with a glum, underdog quality utterly different from pretty much all metal at the time.
1) Tape - literally played it until it snapped
2) LP - bought years later in a fit of nostalgia - still sounds great and has (to me) one of the greatest album covers (and back covers) of the era.
THE VELVET UNDERGROUND - LOADED
One of my favourite albums of all time. Vastly underrated, this may not be raw and druggy but it's GREAT. Doug Yule is often maligned, but his Lou-Reed-only-nicer voice suits the songs perfectly and the album has a great late 60s atmosphere.
1) Tape (can't find, so no photo) - bought in the early 90s. Despite being a VU fan since high school I had somehow never heard Loaded and presumed it sucked. Heard it, it didn't, bought it.
2) 'Fully Loaded' special edition. For once, not bought for convenience, but because it has a whole alternate version of the album, plus unedited versions of the songs from the normal version, just a great reissue.
KISS - LOTS OF ALBUMS
All of them up to Asylum
I bought the first Kiss album on LP for 50p in a charity shop in the mid 90s, just because of the cover. I surprisingly loved the album (had never been a big Kiss fan before) and bought most of their albums on CD. Then ended up buying them all on LP: Kiss is at least 50% aesthetics. Which doesn't explain why I have two copies of Music from the Elder
NEW FAST AUTOMATIC DAFFODILS - PIGEONHOLE
Very atypical Manchester indie album, released at the height of 'baggy' but very much parallel to, rather than part of the movement. Funky, percussive and nicely produced. Nothing they did after this debut was half as idiosyncratic or good.
1) Tape, bought (I think) just after seeing the band support The Charlatans in 1991(?), much played, then forgotten about
2) LP, came across in charity shop in early 2000s, bought in fit of nostalgia, turned out to still be good.
Iron Maiden - S/T (LP & CD)
Cranes - Wings of Joy (tape & LP)
The Smiths - every album (tape, CD, LP)
Slayer - South of Heaven (tape & CD)
The Beatles - The Beatles (White album) (tape & CD), Beatles for Sale, Revolver, Sgt Pepper, Magical Mystery Tour, Abbey Road (LP & CD)
The Velvet Underground & Nico (tape & CD)
Tom Waits - Nighthawks at the Diner, Blue Valentine, Swordfishtrombones (LP & CD)
The Paul Simon Songbook (CD & LP)
Simon & Garfunkel - Sounds of Silence (CD & LP)
I hope this makes up for all the home taping that I did in the 80s